Producing a definitive Tier List of Storybook Brawl Heros is a difficult process, even after the many, many games I’ve played. Before giving my list I just want to touch on the problems associated with it.
The first issue is that, by design, the Heros in Storybook Brawl require you to approach the game in different ways. That’s good, it brings variety. However it means that a Hero who suits my preferred style of play might not be good for you and I might win more often with that Hero than you would. Personally I find the Evil characters fit my play style, which is probably why I’ve had more success with Krampus than Mrs Klaus. In addition, a Hero’s strength will be affected by who the opposing Heros are and whether they’re competing for the same characters.
One of the big differences between Heros is the extent on which they rely on luck. Some people like a game to be RNG heavy (especially if they’re naturally lucky!) but others want to minimise the effect of luck. Again, that will afffect whether you love or hate certain Heros.
Then there’s the fact that the game’s makers (Good Luck Games) are, of course, trying to balance things so there’s no ‘best’ or ‘worst’ Hero. They undoubtedly have databases and spreadsheets from many thousands of games to look at.
So, having explained why a Hero tier list is probably a bad idea, here’s mine!
(Last update: 8th September 2021)
|Storybook Brawl Tier List|
|Tier||Base Heros||Additional Heros|
Morgan le Fey
Pup The Magic Dragon
The Cursed King
Note that ‘Mask’ isn’t included as he’s more of a meta-hero. Mihri, Lion King and Fallen Angel aren’t included because I haven’t had enough experience playing them yet.
I’ll be updating the tier list from time to time based on my play experience and any game patches, so check back for the latest version.